Skip to content
Why Does Leadership Development Need to Start Earlier and Reach Further?

Why Does Leadership Development Need to Start Earlier and Reach Further?

Key Takeaways: Many leadership programs still reach only a small group of people on a fixed calendar, while the role they prepare leaders for now includes guiding teams through restructuring and AI adoption. Employees notice the difference, with only 65% saying leadership development prepares leaders for the real challenges they face, while just 57% say advancement opportunities are awarded fairly. The research suggests development works better when it starts earlier and continues after the program ends.

Leadership development is often organized around a few people and a set schedule: High-potential employees join a cohort; new managers complete a workshop sometime in their first year. Meanwhile, leaders are also being asked to guide teams through restructuring or AI adoption. They are expected to keep employees confident when the path ahead is unclear. Perceptyx’s new Leadership Development guidebook looks at how organizations can close that gap. It draws on Perceptyx benchmark data, Workforce Panel research, and the Great Management Meltdown study.

Why Has Leadership Development Failed to Keep Pace with the Role?

Many leaders are not getting the preparation the job now requires. In Perceptyx’s Great Management Meltdown research, 58% of managers said they would give up managing people if they could, and nearly half said their jobs had become more challenging over the past year. Around 80% had received some form of management training. However, nearly half said it was identical for everyone in their role, which means a manager who already communicates well may sit in the same course as one who struggles to.

Employees can tell when development is not matched to the work. In our Workforce Panel, 65% say leadership development prepares leaders for the real challenges they face. That figure is 83% among fully engaged employees, compared with 46% among those who are not fully engaged. The gap is especially visible with AI. Perceptyx’s Managing in the Age of AI report found that 60% of managers feel prepared to manage employees whose work is augmented by AI. Across the full panel, only 43% of employees say managers at their organization are prepared to lead teams where AI completes parts of the work.

The guidebook suggests building development around the specific situations leaders face once they return to their teams, such as delivering difficult news or deciding how a new AI tool fits into the team’s work. Practice with those situations is more likely to carry over than a framework that made sense in the classroom.

Who Actually Gets Access to Leadership Development?

When development is reserved for a short list of high-potentials, employees outside that group may conclude that leadership roles are out of reach. Only 57% of employees in the Perceptyx Benchmark Database say advancement opportunities are awarded fairly, with favorability ranging from 54% among individual contributors to 80% among executives. Mentoring reaches people unevenly as well. Among employees aged 18 to 24, 79% say they have a mentor who helps with their career, compared with 54% of those 65 and older.

Confidence in senior leaders varies in a similar pattern. Overall, 68% of employees say they trust senior management, from 86% among executives to 66% among individual contributors.Trust in senior leadership also declines with tenure, falling from 76% in an employee’s first year to 64% by three to five years.

To widen the pipeline, the guidebook recommends starting development earlier and adding nomination paths that go beyond manager referrals. It also suggests sharing the criteria used to identify emerging leaders, then allowing employees to nominate themselves.Clear criteria show employees what to work toward and help leaders recognize talent outside their own networks.

Why Does Follow-Through Determine Whether Development Sticks?

Formal programs can introduce new leadership behaviors, but leaders return to full calendars once they end. Without follow-through, most fall back on the approaches they used before. Perceptyx’s State of Learning & Development research found that among employees who say learning helps them perform more effectively, 82% say their manager encourages them to apply new skills, compared with 23% of those who do not see that benefit. Leaders need that same reinforcement: regular coaching conversations with their own manager and a follow-up 360 assessment several months after the initial program ends.

Personalization drives lasting behavior change. In our Workforce Panel research, employees whose development was personalized and informed by their own feedback were more than three times as likely to report lasting behavior change (92% vs. 30%). However, only 34% of HR leaders say their organization measures behavior through employee listening or other tools.

The same gap affects how programs are evaluated. Attendance and satisfaction scores indicate whether a program was delivered, but they do not measure the extent to which employees are experiencing better leadership. Leaders and their teams often see it differently, with 61% of managers in the Great Management Meltdown research giving themselves top marks for their performance while 51% of employees rated their own manager that highly.

The guidebook recommends measuring a short set of leadership items for each participant’s team before a program begins, at a midpoint check-in, and again six to 12 months later. A change in how teams experience their leader says more about impact than any participant satisfaction score.

How Can Organizations Apply These Findings?

The guidebook turns these ideas into questions for senior leaders, HR leaders, managers, and employees. It also identifies five points in the employee lifecycle where leadership development has the most influence, along with metrics for tracking progress. Each section includes specific actions organizations can take to widen access, personalize content, and measure whether leaders are actually leading differently after a program ends.

Download the Leadership Development guidebook.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is Leadership Development?

Leadership development is the process organizations use to build the skills, judgment, and behaviors leaders need to manage teams and drive results. It can include formal programs such as workshops and cohort training, along with ongoing support such as coaching, mentoring, and 360-degree feedback. Effective leadership development matches the specific challenges a leader faces. Only 65% of employees say leadership development prepares leaders for the real challenges they face.

What Are Some Examples of Leadership Development?

Common examples of leadership development include cohort programs, new manager workshops, one-on-one coaching, mentoring, 360-degree feedback, and on-the-job assignments such as cross-functional projects or change initiatives. Formal programs can introduce behaviors, but follow-through determines whether they persist. In Perceptyx research, employees whose development was personalized and informed by their own feedback were more than three times as likely to report lasting behavior change (92% vs. 30%).

What Is the 70-20-10 Rule for Leadership Development?

The 70-20-10 rule for leadership development is a model that suggests 70% of learning comes from on-the-job experience, 20% comes from interactions with others such as coaching or mentoring, and 10% comes from formal training. The model reinforces that classroom instruction alone is not enough. In Perceptyx’s research, 82% of employees who find learning effective say their manager encourages them to apply new skills, compared with 23% of those who do not.

Subscribe to our blog

Opt-in for our weekly recap and never miss a post.

Getting started is easy

Advance from data to insights to focused action